When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, which supports our community. Sig P220, 224, 226, M400 TREAD, 516 G2 Patrol SBR, 716i TREAD, MPX K, 1911 Emperor Scorpion Fastback, 1911 TACOPS Carry, 1911 Ultra Carry. Youtube has de-funded most gun content. Design perfection attained. The full-length slide rails are on the inside of the frame, which lets the slide sit deeper, lowering the bore axis to reduce felt recoil and muzzle flip. Required fields are marked *. Given the size of the P227's grip makes it hard to recommend over other double-stack .45s like the HK45, HK USP, CZ 97, SAR K2-45, or even striker-fired guns like . I had already read it and that is where my question originated since the Sig p220 is a John Browning design same as the M1911a1.The following paragraph illustrates this fact. IMO the P220 is also an incredibly well-designed and well-built handgun. This is the correct-weight factory replacement recoil spring for SIG P220 pistols in .45 ACP and P226 pistols in .40 S&W / .357 SIG. Controls shot, right side. I own a Glock 21, and while I like it, the grip is that of a brick, it feels terrible in my hand, it has had several failures to eject over the years, the trigger is spongy, and its not as accurate as my P220. Its time to look at another popular debate. Heres the short version answer why Sig P220 trumps the 1911: Now heres the long version of this bickering: Ive always been a Sig Sauer fan and it all started when I got my first Sig Sauer P226 then wandered over to the P220 in .45 ACP years ago. Best Selling Rifles; . Not a bad article, but anytime flat statements are made, reasonable people must speak up, Id put a P220 up against any new .45 on the market with complete confidence. But the gun had other advantages, too. Funny how that works when only one manufacturer makes a gun. Although even with people who should know better, the gun has always been rated high in Snob Appeal (only because it was made in Germany originally) reality is another story. Get the 76th edition of the World's Greatest Gun Book. I'm Mike, one of the oldest writer of Sniper Country! The first thing that jumps out is the two-tone look is the result of combining an anodized barrel, action, and slide combined with a Flat Dark Earth alloy frame . 1 of 2 Go to page. March 13, 2015. My Compact was a bit odd-feeling from the way SIG chopped the frame. Its a massive gun thats heavy and wide and sports a very wide grip for a single stack gun. With a 3.9-inch barrel and weight of 30 ounces, the P220 carry is the ideal . NO JAMS. Mason's Rifle Room. Please consider supporting me on Patreon!https://www.patreon.com/jeffshootsstuffI apologize that this video was uploa. Please select the desired spring weight from the drop-down menu. Come join the discussion about optics, hunting, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more! With the Sig, most generally you will not need a set of files to swap parts. Mfg: Viridian Weapon Technologies. In my own testing although accuracy was good (at least with the German Made guns) the P226 9mm was always inferior to old fashioned classic guns like the Original High Power or Neuhausen P210 or CZ 75 or THE FABULOUS STAR MODEL 30 which was the BEST HANDGUN OF THE 20TH/21st.CENTURY which actually endured 180,000 round wear tests, try that with any other modern plasticky or stamped sheet metal pistol. Made to the same high standards as the parts already found in your Sig Sauer firearm. Makes for a nice little party trick, by the way. Im not saying that you need to be a rocket scientist to run a 1911, but it takes more far attention to the pistol, safety, and handling. Grips, sights, trigger kits etc. Where to Buy Ammo Online [Complete 2021 Guide], Best Gun Cleaning Kits [AR-15, Pistol & Universal], Best Shooting Gloves [Hands-On Tested, 2021 Update], Best Universal Red Dot Sights [Hands-on Review], Best AR-10 Magazines: Ultimate Buyers Guide. Fits Sig Sauer P220 and P226 - Stainless. While I haven't read about the barrel link, I would think it is also a weak spot for 1911 in 10mm. And, of course, it is much faster to reload, and its flat magazines are much more discreet and comfortable to carry than speedloaders for a revolver when concealment is the order of the day. The ergonomic carry pistol is loaded with top-grade features which make it a gun any firearms enthusiast would be proud to own. I've got a P220, Glock 20 and RIA 1911 in 10. Colt 1911 VS SIG Sauer P220. Next, eject the magazine. I'll take a P220 SAO over almost anything else. Who makes the first ten guns that pop up? No need to tamper with anything on Sig P220If you get a Sig P220 with the Siglite night sights, you dont need to do anything else to it. I prefer this design to something like Glock, which digs into my hand like crazy. You train through this process. you know, just like 1911 drivers train to clear stoppages, disassemble full-length guide rods, or be just a little too smug. A Sig Sauer P220 only needs to be run one way: hammer down on a loaded chamber. Different actions but they have a similar feel to me. The author has seen duty belts weighing in the 15- to 20-pound range once festooned with multiple handcuffs, a full-sized baton, heavy flashlight, portable radio, and ammunition. Very interesting question! Revolver or semi-auto, it doesnt matter to me. Sig P220-P229-SP 2022-Sig 1911-M400. As you can probably tell, the P220 SAO is my favorite in either caliber. It will probably need a fluff n buff to make it feed defensive ammo, too. Both the above problems stemmed from the fact that the empty case being ejected was actually pushing down on the top loaded round in the magazine and the rim of the ejected round would often catch on the mouth of the round waiting to be loaded or in the case of the lead bullet actually plow a groove through the shoulder and then peel back the case mouth like a banana resulting in a catastrophic jam with the loaded round on its way into the chamber. I apologize for the misinformation, guys. Internally, Sig's new compact cannondubbed the "P245"shared little with the P220. *Spoken like a good Beretta shooter bhp0!. or quality 1911 (Awesome/Expensive!) Sig borrowed the inferior mainspring position which resulted in the mainspring being positioned outside the back strap and covered only by the flimsy plasticky grips. Sig Sauer Recoil Springs - 14, 16, 18 and 20 Lbs.Fits all P220, P226, P227 models (DASA, SAO, Elite, Legion, 220/226 "S" etc.) Second Media Corp., 111 Peter Street, Suite 600, Toronto, Ontario, M5V 2H1, Canada. Grayguns Fat Guide Rod - Sig P228/P229 - Super Black. Fire Control Unit is the term used by Sig to describe the bundle of parts the ATF considers the firearm. The model we are reviewing today is a .45 ACP model. For those looking for an excellent mid-sized carry 1911, check out the 4.25-inch commander S&W 1911SC E-Series. Thankfully, Sig seems to have had access to a crystal ball. Yet, there are still debates among the hard core users. Factory replacement recoil spring guide rod for SIG GSR 1911 models. SIG SAUER's recoil springs fit any SIG SAUER pistol, rifle or other firearm. The P220 Carry is a shortened version of the full-size P220. JavaScript is disabled. My model is very plain, and very much a 1970 combat pistol. If you were in a situation where you knew people would be shooting back at you, and you could only choose between a Sig P220 or a 1911, both loaded with modern hollow point defense ammo, which would you grab? I am wondering if I should go with a quality 1911 or the sig p220 and stick with the same design as my p226? . Only our P320-F (Full-Size) guide rod and P320 X-Five (Full Size) include a 15-pound 1911 recoil spring. I have a P220 carry stainless and a 1911 Carry stainless. While the world has moved to 9mm pistols and polymer-frame guns, the SIG P220 is a defiant old man telling kids to get off his lawn. This is a constant problem for me. JavaScript is disabled. Magazines Magazines. ReliabilityThis first reason a Sig P220 is better than a 1911 is a no-brainer. The slide lock position is towards the rear of the gun, which creates an issue for many who like a nice high thumbs-forward grip. Like. It's just so much smoother than the other two and I think I can shoot it more accurately. Taught me a lot about SIG at 45 caliber, and did nothing to take away from the appreciation I learned, FOR SIG, from a 9mm P239. Sig Sauer P220 for sale for low prices, with quick shipping, excellent customer service, and a lifetime warranty. The P220 always fit most hands well. The magazine release button is large and textured which makes it easy to find and reach with the thumb. (not CA). It's a heavy beast best described as a boat anchor. They are manufactured with proper materials, hardened and stress-relieved to withstand a lifetime of hard use. A Colt all steel Delta Elite would be hard to beat. I love both my Sig Tacops 1911 and my P220 Carry Elite. Photo Gallery: 14 Amazing Engraved Guns of Gun Digest 2015, Redding Releases a Number of New Precision Reloading Die Sets, SIG P365 Rose Review: The Pistols Petals And Thorns, The .380 ACP Glock 28 Is Now Available Stateside, First Look: Bond Arms Cyclops .45-70 Govt. If you have any feedback or question about my articles, please submit it here, it's always appreciated! Smith & Wesson SW1911SC E-Series. However I would suspect in a torture test the steel framed Colt would outlast the aluminum framed Sig. This is where the slide impacts when cycling. Sources: Monkey Wrench, Sig Sauer, Colt, Drew Perez, Only one company builds Sig P220s (but, TJ is the man that can customize to your needs). Other than that, this model is an exciting step back into the late 70s and early 80s. kygunco.com . Polymer Derangement Syndrome is a Crazy Mental Disorder. You think all those guns, with sell prices ranging from $499 to over $2,000, all have the same level of quality standards? My range rents both 1911s and 220s. I will champion the following statement till the day I die: Anything the 1911 can do, the Sig Sauer P220 can do better. I hear it happens. COLT O1911C-SS38 - 38 SUPER SERIES 70, N.M. BARREL ,CLASSIC GOVERMENT, STAINLESS STEEL FINISH, CUSTOM HAND ENGRAVED SLIDE & FRAME, CUSTOM WHITE PEARLITE GRIPS WITH COLT GOLD RAMPANT HORSE .Click for more info. In fact, the P245 takes the exact same spring used on the .40/.357 P239s (and the .40/.357 Sig Pros). Ill get more into this aspect a little . When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, which supports our community. I cant argue the symbolism, patriotism, and outright hell YEAH! that holding a kickass 1911 brings forth. If you have a tight budget but want a high-quality pistol, you can get these guns for around 400 bucks. Which models would you find comparable ? After some time, the weapon was imported under SIGs trademark because of SIGs success and growth. The Franken-.45. The lightweight Commander was dubbed by one of its greatest advocates, Col. Jeff Cooper, as a gun designed to be carried much and shot seldom. Most who had fired it considered it much more unpleasant to shoot than its big brother, the full-sized, all-steel Government Model. It always had good sights compared to most of its competition. Now lets face facts no company these days uses quality parts unless they absolutely have to and Sig would have never dropped the econo-grade stamped slide because they wanted too. In stainless, the full-size P220 is a fairly massive handgun, and feels far bigger and chunkier that the 1911. Sig P220 Combat - Much lighter (follow ups are slightly slower, recoil is more jumpy), tougher and more durable, fits with my active rugged lifestyle, double action and stupid simple, easy to carry. (Though, oddly enough, 9mm, 10mm, .38 Super and .22LR are other available calibers for both pistols). I prefer the DA/SA feature of the P220, the decocker, and the lack of a manual safety. The SIG 220s, 226s and 1911s are all awesome. "If I'd known I'd live this long I'd have taken better care of myself.". Thanks for the input so far. Romans 1:16- "For I am not ashamed of the Gospel of Christ" Do we not read throughout the Scriptures that Christ is the King? The guns recoil is minimal and best described with an Awe. The weight helps cut recoil, and the fat bottom grip helps displace it in the hand. I already have a P220 SAO Carry two tone, P220 SAO two tone, P220 SAO Dark Elite, P220 SAO Legion, P220 SAO Match and a P220 SAO Super Match. It's beyond a stretch to call that an "evolution"they are different animals. Therefore, the P220 was created. Sold the Glocks. Indeed, its popularity is exceeded only by that of the Colt M1911 Government Model, whose king-of-the-hill status the P220 is now seriously challenging, especially in law enforcement circles. Chuck continued, The P220 is a simple design, perhaps as simple as a handgun can be and still work. I prefer the 220. Kimber Aegis Elite Custom (sold); 9mm Springfield Loaded Stainless (sold); Kimber Stainless Custom II (sold); Dan Wesson Valor; Les Baer Custom Carry (sold); Wilson Combat X Tac; Guncrafter Industries No Name (sold); Springfield 1911-A1 "Custom . I have to change recoil springs to go from modern weak 10mm to "real" 10mm in the Glock and the 1911. The fact that a single pistol with which the officer is intensively trained could be used on or off duty, in uniform or in plainclothes, is another big factor in the P220s favor when police departments look at purchasing new sidearms. As a matter of fact there is one roll pin in the top of the frame that has its rear end hanging out in thin air and is pressed down on by a very strong spring. For instance, SIGs flagship handguns, the P series, were born from the P220. A Critical Look at the SIG-Sauer P225 . It was certainly truth in advertising. The frame of the P series guns is made of aluminum and as every knows who has used both aluminum framed versus steel frame guns the aluminum frame guns are inferior in regards to losing accuracy because they wear away quicker and are damaged more easily in an accidental dropping or fall. It is a fantastic gun for the range and to experience a Swiss 1911 in many ways. This is the standard Nitron finish P220 Carryas good as it gets for personal defense. In conclusion a Colt/Browning this gun certainly is not and never can come close to being ever. I grew to like it more and was carrying it lots until that fateful Sig Sauer fell in my lap courtesy of a friend. However, the P220 has been chambered in 9mm (9mm vs 10mm), .45 ACP (10mm vs .45 ACP), .38 Super, 10mm, 9mm Steyr, 7.6521 Parabellum, and there is even a .22 LR model. We may earn a commission when you purchase through the links on our site. As far as capacity, nine rounds of .45acp are all that is needed out of a defensive pistol. These days, its easy to buy a cheap laser to mount onto your pistol or rifle. Grayguns fat Stainless Steel Guide Rods are available for the P320, P228, P229, P220 and P226. Along with those I have four other 45acp 1911s. Sig Sauer P226 Legion Full-Size 9Mm 4.4In 3X15Rd. of spring force to ensure reliable . There is no comparison between the two in terms of format and function. In DAO, the points made about staging the pull reliably and at the same release point in the article referring to SIGs common DA/SA trigger, is spot on and reminds me of the same sense of control I notice in my S&W 340PD revolver. With origins dating back to the late 1970s, the P220 is considered by many to be the one that started it all for SIG SAUER. FYI, with heavy loads the SigP220 is the more comfortable pistol to shoot, much more comfortable grips and ergomatics! Itll probably keep you reasonably safe in a bullseye match but I still would lay odds that a nice P220 Match Elite will probably kick the crap out of a 1911 Gold Cup at the target range too. 5. Sorry, but John Moses Browning in all his wisdom still made you lower your hammer manually, which is less safe by definition. The guide rods are guaranteed for life. Ergonomics * * * * *. Done. The duty belt carries a great deal of equipment. These guns are big soft shooting, accurate, and reliable babies. Second Media Corp., 111 Peter Street, Suite 600, Toronto, Ontario, M5V 2H1, Canada. The designation changed to Pistol, Caliber .45, Automatic, M1911A1 in the Vietnam War era. If you live in a state that has magazine restrictions the SIG P220s low capacity may be a perfect choice for a home defense gun. Do you think you could take those ten guns and disassemble them all and throw their parts in a pile, then make ten completely new, fully functional guns with those jumbled-up parts? Reducing the weight of the duty .45 from 39.5 ounces to 25.7 (the same round-count of the same ammunition adds the same weight to either) results in a 13.8-ounce weight saving almost a pound at a critical point. That is the best way to compare it to feeling the P220. There is always this never-ending 1911 vs Glock argument. The two guns are as different as night and day. The P220 has an overall length of 7.8 inches, is 1.5 inches wide, and is 5.5 inches high. Right off, I'm referring specifically to the Legion. The TISAS 1911A1 with a WWII-like holster and mag pouch available from Sarco. They paid the price of a reduced in-gun cartridge capacity, only five to six rounds. In stock. Nothing bit the shooter. My 220 has been flawless from the first round. Thanks for this and the other comments pointing out the error. They are very similar and also very different. When you buy a 1911, well, Id guess youd have to say that depends. Yes, I know having a variety of manufacturers increases accessibility to the masses due to gentler price tags. The more modern base models sport a rail for a light or laser, as well as night sights. The Fora platform includes forum software by XenForo. Get gun deals, hand's on reviews, educational content and updates on law changes, daily! The long, heavy double-action pull required to initially unleash the firepower of the P220 was much like that of the revolvers that were so much a part of their institutional history. And probably settle for a Ruger SR1911 just to get that into my collection. The gun weighs 1.9 pounds unloaded. As you can see this Mickey Mouse system is much inferior to the Colt/Browning system. While known more for their revolvers and M&P pistols, S&W should not be overlooked when it comes to 1911s. The only change/improvements I made on any of my P series Sigs were flat triggers on curved trigger models and #10 Trijicon rear sights on the Legion .45 and 10mm as I don't like a combat hold. Accuracy is always excellent. The P220 has a 4.4-inch barrel and is an all-metal gun. The history on those two pistols I cited doesn't change just because you don't like the narrative, and a supposedly 'newer, awesomer' version doesn't make the previous version less prone to failure with the full power 10mm ammo (Norma 10mm and other) the FBI and others were testing with at that time. The Rifle section is dedicated to James Henry Mason, aka forum member "horse"; shooter, collector and rifle authority, who left us too soon. The pistol was originally developed for the Swiss Army, and officially adopted by them in 1975, chambered in 9mm. One of those guns was a well-worn P220 European, the other, a brand new P220 American. SIG Sauer P220. Unsubscribe at any time. Price is certainly a factor, as is the caliber, both of which may not appeal to some. ), HK (Nice!)) Check and mate. The gun lacks manual safety. Its straight, groove-free, with a very comfortable palm swell at the bottom of the grip. A base model 1911 often rubs me the wrong way, but the P220 is a soft shooting, easy recoiling gun. The single action trigger has a slight bit of take up, but you meet the wall quickly. Yell at me all you want, I know I'm right after years of using both platforms -- and here's my justification. They will drag you down to their level and beat you with experience.". With an inside-the-waistband holster and proper clothing, the P220 virtually disappears into concealment. They are two distinct animals other than the commonality of caliber. As a retired officer of the Swiss Air Force it annoys me. Area Code: 928. The nice thing is since you have a 226 things will be the same. The P220 uses an enlargement of the chamber locks onto the ejection port of the slide. The P220 in DA/SA includes a reduced and contoured Elite beavertail, which allows for a higher grip and a reduced profile, thus eliminating printing. When it comes to 1911s, it's really about the individual manufacturer, and the quality of the build. And, that is taking your gun a part for cleaning. Gun deals, hand's on reviews, educational content and news on law changes, every day! With handguns from Glock or even SIGs own P320, I have to back my finger out just a bit to rest the tip of my finger on the trigger. Nearly all the advantages of a 1911 with the ability to rack and chamber check with the manual safety engaged. The gun was and is extremely reliable. I wouldn't write that in stone but I do recall reading that. ), load them in the magazine, and then feed them through the pistol, one after another. DA/SA Full-Sized Pistol Chambered in 45 ACP . {Pope Pius XI, Dec 11, 1925.}. This part will help keep your Sig Sauer Firearm in top shooting condition. Is Colts customer service widely lauded as exceptional? Sig P220 45 Dark sig finish, 4.3" bbl . With a hair more pressure you get the trigger break. Something to think about before you pick up that 1911. The 1911 was never built for the round. A prolific author, Ayoob is the author of Gun Digest Book of Concealed Carry, Gun Digest Book of SIG-Sauer, Gun Digest Book of Combat Handgunnery, Massad Ayoob's Greatest Handguns of the World and many other books and more than one thousand articles on firearms, combat techniques, self-defense, and legal issues. Recoil Spring Set - P220 Carry . I will say this though ever since first shooting my sig I haven't shot any other handgun. Reliability. as others will tell you, no collection is complete without a 1911. . In stock. Four shots went into roughly 1-1/4 inches. (1) A fan of SIGs compact single-stack 9mm, Mullin added, Although the P220 is not as good as a P225, I would rate it the top weapon that I tested in .45 ACP. (Mullins emphasis.). Has a higher bore axis, parts and mags are expensive. Ive another example of the W. German mfgd P220 built with the classic European magazine release at the bottom of the grip. SHORT RESET TRIGGER KIT SIG SAUER P220. Ive had both, for me, the sig is hands down the best platform foe ten mil. Unsubscribe at any time. Now, the P220 .45 gives the plainclothes officer a much more attractive option. Unless you spend the dough for an already upgraded 1911 with enhanced accessories, your run of the mill original design GI-style 1911A1 will have miserable sights, no beavertail on the grip safety, standard safety size, and probably a little short trigger that has a pull that ranges anywhere from mediocre to acceptable. I know most of you 1911 guys and gals are sputtering, yeah, but! and stating counterpoint after counterpoint based on different models and options and personal opinions. SIG is known for its quality handguns, and this one is no different. Add to Cart. Its beyond a stretch to call that an evolutionthey are different animals. I don't think they have any 220. Sig is slightly easier to field strip and reassemble. There, I said it. At the time this was a combat handgun that was hard to beat and shooting is taking a step back to the Cold War. No jams. In the P220, the low-pressure .45 cartridge simply drives the slide back with a gentle bump. At the time, I was sporting a Colt M1991A1 that I had spent hours working on, lovingly going through and modifying, upgrading to suit my needs so it would run reliably.I had used the Colt in many tactics and self defense courses, and was comfortable with it. Reliability is top notch. Contributing Editor. I think a CZ 97B might be a closer comparison in manual of arms at least to a 1911 since it has a manual safety and not a decocker like a DA/SA P220. The breech block of the P220, being a separate piece, isolates the frame from the shock of direct impacts. Slim-ish width, great grip angle and comfortable Hogue rubber grips make it feel great in the hand. Price $29.99. The stresses are distributed to both sides of the frame at the large diameter take down lever pin. The temptation is overwhelming to bestow it on somebody.". Citadel 1911 Review: Best Budget-Friendly Pistol? The G21 has a polymer frame; the SIG's is alloy. Comparing two awesome .45 ACP pistol designs for SHTF. Easy to DisassembleThis is just another thing that these two crowds will bicker over. It holds eight rounds of .45 ACP in a single stack magazine. You will not be regretting it. The foot of the barrel on a 1911 is not as robust as that of the P220, due to its size and split design for the link. If this pin snaps off or becomes loose it will fall down into the guns mechanism hopelessly jamming the gun up tight, just what you need in a gun fight to the death. High among these was the double-action first shot mechanism. Have not had an issue with shooting either one and I enjoy both, fell in love with the P220 when they first came out.